diff --git a/src/timer.cpp b/src/timer.cpp
index e9e6114ea..454696385 100644
--- a/src/timer.cpp
+++ b/src/timer.cpp
@@ -8,7 +8,6 @@
 #include <algorithm>
 #include <cerrno>
 #include <chrono>
-#include <cmath>
 #include <cstddef>
 #include <ctime>
 
@@ -129,13 +128,13 @@ wcstring timer_snapshot_t::print_delta(timer_snapshot_t t1, timer_snapshot_t t2,
     auto unit_short_name = [](tunit unit) {
         switch (unit) {
             case tunit::minutes:
-                return "min";
+                return "mins";
             case tunit::seconds:
-                return "sec";
+                return "secs";
             case tunit::milliseconds:
-                return "ms";
+                return "millis";
             case tunit::microseconds:
-                return "\u03BCs";
+                return "micros";
         }
         // GCC does not recognize the exhaustive switch above
         return "";
@@ -153,7 +152,7 @@ wcstring timer_snapshot_t::print_delta(timer_snapshot_t t1, timer_snapshot_t t2,
                 return micros / 1.0;
         }
         // GCC does not recognize the exhaustive switch above
-        return std::nan("");
+        return 0.0;
     };
 
     auto wall_unit = get_unit(net_wall_micros);
@@ -166,9 +165,9 @@ wcstring timer_snapshot_t::print_delta(timer_snapshot_t t1, timer_snapshot_t t2,
     if (!verbose) {
         append_format(output,
                       L"\n_______________________________"
-                      L"\nDuration\t%6.3G %s:"
-                      L"\n user time\t%6.3G %s"
-                      L"\n kernel time\t%6.3G %s"
+                      L"\nExecuted in  %6.2F %s"
+                      L"\n   usr time  %6.2F %s"
+                      L"\n   sys time  %6.2F %s"
                       L"\n",
                       wall_time, unit_name(wall_unit), usr_time, unit_name(cpu_unit), sys_time,
                       unit_name(cpu_unit));
@@ -182,9 +181,9 @@ wcstring timer_snapshot_t::print_delta(timer_snapshot_t t1, timer_snapshot_t t2,
 
         append_format(output,
                       L"\n________________________________________________________"
-                      L"\nDuration     %6.3G %s   %*s           %*s "
-                      L"\n user time   %6.3G %s  %6.3G %s  %6.3G %s "
-                      L"\n kernel time %6.3G %s  %6.3G %s  %6.3G %s "
+                      L"\nExecuted in  %6.2F %s   %*s           %*s "
+                      L"\n   usr time  %6.2F %s  %6.2F %s  %6.2F %s "
+                      L"\n   sys time  %6.2F %s  %6.2F %s  %6.2F %s "
                       L"\n",
                       wall_time, unit_short_name(wall_unit), strlen(unit_short_name(wall_unit)) - 1,
                       "fish", strlen(unit_short_name(fish_unit)) - 1, "external", usr_time,
diff --git a/tests/checks/time.fish b/tests/checks/time.fish
index d28f7461d..486108911 100644
--- a/tests/checks/time.fish
+++ b/tests/checks/time.fish
@@ -4,9 +4,9 @@ time sleep 0
 # These are a tad awkward because it picks the correct unit and adapts whitespace.
 # The idea is that it's a table.
 #CHECKERR: ________________________________________________________
-#CHECKERR: Duration {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{\s*}}fish {{\s*}}external
-#CHECKERR: user time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}}
-#CHECKERR: kernel time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}}
+#CHECKERR: Executed in {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{\s*}}fish {{\s*}}external
+#CHECKERR: usr time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}}
+#CHECKERR: sys time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}}
 time for i in (seq 1 2)
     echo banana
 end
@@ -14,17 +14,17 @@ end
 #CHECK: banana
 #CHECK: banana
 #CHECKERR: ________________________________________________________
-#CHECKERR: Duration {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{\s*}}fish {{\s*}}external
-#CHECKERR: user time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}}
-#CHECKERR: kernel time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}}
+#CHECKERR: Executed in {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{\s*}}fish {{\s*}}external
+#CHECKERR: usr time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}}
+#CHECKERR: sys time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}}
 
 # Make sure we're not double-parsing
 time echo 'foo -s   bar'
 #CHECK: foo -s   bar
 #CHECKERR: ________________________________________________________
-#CHECKERR: Duration {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{\s*}}fish {{\s*}}external
-#CHECKERR: user time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}}
-#CHECKERR: kernel time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{ms|μs|sec}}
+#CHECKERR: Executed in {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{\s*}}fish {{\s*}}external
+#CHECKERR: usr time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}}
+#CHECKERR: sys time {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}} {{[\d,.\s]*}} {{millis|micros|secs}}
 
 true && time a=b not builtin true | true
 #CHECKERR: ___{{.*}}